SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

SUBSIM Radio Room Forums (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/index.php)
-   COLD WATERS (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/forumdisplay.php?f=268)
-   -   How many licks does it take to get to the center of a Typhoon? (https://www.subsim.com/radioroom/showthread.php?t=236171)

supraoptimo 01-07-18 12:10 AM

How many licks does it take to get to the center of a Typhoon?
 
Apparently the answer is five Mark 48s and a Harpoon missile.

While doing the last mission of a 1984 campaign, I hit a Typhoon with a pair of Mk 48s. Then another pair after the first pair didn't send him down.. His boat's at a 45 degree angle with his bow sticking out of the water, so I fire my last Mk 48 and it hits. I finally had to get to periscope depth and fire a Harpoon at his bow before he finally sunk.

Capt.Hunt 01-07-18 02:28 AM

Damn, you must have had a lot of bad luck, usually I can sink him with 3 fish.

I have found it quite odd that when you force a soviet sub to throw the chicken switches, they run around with their bow sticking out of the water like that.

GoldenRivet 01-07-18 02:33 AM

The durability of the Typhoon in Cold Waters is greatly exaggerated IMHO

sure, it has design characteristics which are meant to increase its chances of surviving a direct hit by a torpedo - chiefly the parallel pressure hulls - but i seriously doubt the Typhoon could survive two direct hits... certainly not a third, and obviously not 5 and a harpoon missile strike.

I have never taken one out with less than 4 hits personally.

though the survivability of the platform has never been tested in combat, there is no denying it would be a tough nut to crack... but i dont think 5 ADCAPs and a missile tough

Erik 01-07-18 09:50 AM

I sunk one with just two hits. It surfaced and limped around for a while after the second hit, but eventually succumbed to damage and sunk.

Capt.Hunt 01-07-18 02:13 PM

I think it greatly depends on where they're hit, I've seen Tangos and Romeos shrug off a mk 48.

supraoptimo 01-07-18 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Capt.Hunt (Post 2535304)
I have found it quite odd that when you force a soviet sub to throw the chicken switches, they run around with their bow sticking out of the water like that.

Must be all that raw Stalinium used to make Soviet submarines impervious to decadent capitalist torpedoes.

newparade 01-08-18 05:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by supraoptimo (Post 2535388)
Must be all that raw Stalinium used to make Soviet submarines impervious to decadent capitalist torpedoes.

That's also what Wolverine's claws were actually made of.

GorkanCzech 01-13-18 08:06 AM

Are we sure they didnt pull T 34 Again.
Seriously if you dont hit Soviet at right angle he just shrugs it off.
I fear what will happen when Russia gets freaking Bodyarmor.

GSmith63 01-13-18 02:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GoldenRivet (Post 2535305)
The durability of the Typhoon in Cold Waters is greatly exaggerated IMHO

sure, it has design characteristics which are meant to increase its chances of surviving a direct hit by a torpedo - chiefly the parallel pressure hulls - but i seriously doubt the Typhoon could survive two direct hits... certainly not a third, and obviously not 5 and a harpoon missile strike.

I have never taken one out with less than 4 hits personally.

though the survivability of the platform has never been tested in combat, there is no denying it would be a tough nut to crack... but i dont think 5 ADCAPs and a missile tough

I agree. The Typhoons were designed to survive multiple hits by lightweight torpedoes like the Mk. 46, or maybe a near miss by a -48. A direct hit by a Mk. 48 is going to be pretty catastrophic to any undersea vessel. The crew in adjacent compartments might have a better chance of short term survival or successfully completing an emergency blow, but that is probably about it. Best that could be hoped for would probably be a total mission kill, with the sub stuck on the surface and being towed back to port.

Mob1us0ne 01-22-18 04:27 PM

Isn’t the Typhoon basically supposed to be a boss fight more or less?

GSmith63 01-22-18 04:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GSmith63 (Post 2536361)
I agree. The Typhoons were designed to survive multiple hits by lightweight torpedoes like the Mk. 46, or maybe a near miss by a -48. A direct hit by a Mk. 48 is going to be pretty catastrophic to any undersea vessel. The crew in adjacent compartments might have a better chance of short term survival or successfully completing an emergency blow, but that is probably about it. Best that could be hoped for would probably be a total mission kill, with the sub stuck on the surface and being towed back to port.

Of course, with that being said, a real 688 wouldn't be likely to survive a single direct hit from even a lightweight torpedo. Cue realism vs. gameplay discussion!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:09 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © 1995- 2024 Subsim®
"Subsim" is a registered trademark, all rights reserved.