SUBSIM Radio Room Forums

Quote:

Originally Posted by shipkiller1 (Post 2571766)

Its not mathematically impossible. You just do not have the time, mostly.

Added to the fact that you realistically cannot classify a launch transient outside of, lets say 5k... The sonar operator does not know what he heard.. if he heard anything...

Quote:

Originally Posted by ET2SN (Post 2571768)

Chazly; Let's assume we're in DW and you have a sonarman with a waterfall display. What's he seeing and hearing?

OK, he picked up a torpedo in the water.
He needs to tell the OOD something, NOW.
He doesn't have time to calculate range or course, he just has the data.

In terms of DW, all he has time to report is a TIW, its bearing, and whether it sounds like its close or not. Its then up to the OOD to initiate an evasion of some kind.

Keep it practical.:up:
There isn't time to worry about TMA when the bleeping thing was aimed at you. :o

Quote:

Originally Posted by SaltiDawg (Post 2571769)

What ET2SN said! :Kaleun_Applaud:

Agree with you guys completely. I am definitely not implying I would do TMA on a supposed torpedo contact before evasion. First move is get the heck outta there. I'm just getting a little egghead here :D